Why filling every gap in our lives might not be the best use of our time.
I spend a slightly embarrassing amount of time trying to make my life more efficient.
I time-block my calendar.
I automate things in my business.
I have reminders for things I would otherwise forget (often on annual reminders such as having my car serviced).
I combine errands.
I plan self-care (bi-weekly massage, yes please).
I listen to books while doing other things (including falling asleep).
I even find myself calculating whether I can squeeze one more job into the 20 minutes before I need to leave for the school run.
I’m quite good at efficiency.
And, until recently, I assumed that was entirely a good thing.
Then one of my MBA lectures suggested something that felt completely counterintuitive:
Efficiency can actually make a system more vulnerable.
The lecture was about technology and organisations, but the basic argument was fairly simple.
When we optimise something too tightly for one particular set of circumstances, it works brilliantly... until those circumstances change.
There is no slack.
No spare capacity.
No room for error.
No alternative way of doing things.
The lecturer used the pandemic as an example. Businesses that had been optimised to operate efficiently under normal conditions suddenly found themselves in circumstances that were anything but normal. Some simply didn’t have enough flexibility in their systems to adapt.
And obviously, I started thinking about my own life.
Because haven’t we done exactly the same thing to ourselves? We’ve become obsessed with removing the gaps.
If we have an hour-long commute, we listen to a podcast.
If we go for a walk, we make a phone call.
If we’re cooking dinner, we reply to messages.
If we have ten minutes between meetings, we check our emails.
If our children are happily occupied for twenty minutes...
Quick. DO SOMETHING PRODUCTIVE.
We’ve become remarkably good at filling every available bit of space.
And perhaps we’ve started confusing that with using our time well.
What if the gaps aren’t wasted time?
One of the things I found most interesting in the lecture was the defence of what businesses might consider “redundancy”.
Spare capacity.
Duplication.
Room in the system that isn’t being used to its absolute maximum.
Because that apparently ‘inefficient’ space can give people time to reflect, reconsider, tolerate mistakes and respond to uncertainty.
That feels remarkably relevant to life.
Maybe the half-hour with nothing planned isn’t a problem to solve.
Maybe having energy left at the end of the working day isn’t evidence that you could have done more.
Maybe an afternoon with the kids that doesn’t achieve anything doesn’t need an activity squeezed into it.
Maybe staring out of the window on a train is allowed.
Maybe we don’t need to listen to something while we’re walking.
Maybe boredom even has a purpose.
Because the problem with running your life at 100% capacity is that life rarely behaves exactly as planned.
A child gets ill.
A client needs something unexpected.
Someone you love needs you out of the blue.
The car breaks down.
Work becomes unexpectedly difficult.
Or perhaps you’re simply knackered.
And suddenly the beautifully optimised system falls apart.
I don’t want to optimise the humanity out of my life
I should probably say that I’m not about to throw away my calendar.
Efficiency is useful.
Technology is useful.
Systems are essential.
And I’m certainly not advocating deliberately making life more difficult.
That’s not really the point the lecture was making either.
The argument was that technology should support human judgement, rather than replacing it, and that the complexity of organisations means we can’t assume tidier and more automated always equals better.
I think there’s something in that for us, too.
The goal shouldn’t be to extract the maximum possible productivity from every hour we’re awake. Because we’re not machines.
Our lives need some margin.
Time to think.
Time to change our minds.
Time to have conversations that go on longer than expected.
Time to notice things.
Time to rest without turning rest into another performance metric.
And perhaps even some time that serves absolutely no obvious purpose whatsoever.
I’m still going to organise my calendar.
I’m still going to automate boring tasks.
And I’ll almost definitely still see a spare 20 minutes and wonder what I can get done.
But I’m starting to question whether an efficient life and a good life are necessarily the same thing.
Perhaps some of the space I’ve been trying so hard to optimise away is actually the space I need most.